
Supreme Court grants bail to two Bilkis Bano convicts
They can leave prison during appeals, but their convictions remain and the court has not cleared them of the crimes.
Overview
Two men convicted in the can leave prison on , but they have not been cleared of the crimes. The Supreme Court paused the of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya after more than 17 years in prison. It cited Joshi’s severe disability and said their appeals raise important legal and factual questions. A trial court will decide the release conditions. Their convictions and appeals remain in place.
The order follows the court’s that Gujarat could not reduce their sentences because the trial took place in Maharashtra. It cancelled the of all 11 convicts and sent them back to prison. The latest decision lets these two leave while their cases continue, but it does not erase their convictions or settle the appeals.
Timeline
The two convicts remained convicted while their appeals continued after the bail order
The order allowed temporary release during the pending appeals, not . Bail permits release while proceedings continue, and suspension of sentence pauses imprisonment during that period; is an executive reduction or ending of a sentence, while overturns a conviction. Joshi and Modhiya therefore remain convicted unless their appeals succeed, and their release depends on the trial court’s conditions.
The Supreme Court suspended the life sentences of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya and granted them bail
The Court cited the two men’s incarceration for more than 17 years and noted Joshi’s severe handicap. It found that factual and legal issues remained to be decided in their appeals, suspended the of their sentences, and ordered their release on conditions to be fixed by the trial court.
The 11 convicts surrendered after the Supreme Court restored their life sentences
The convicts returned to prison after the Court rejected requests for more time and reaffirmed its surrender direction. The ruling restored their custody and life sentences, but it did not decide every issue in their individual appeals. It also did not permanently prevent a convict from later seeking bail or through the ordinary appellate process.
The Supreme Court quashed Gujarat’s remission orders and required all 11 convicts to return to prison
The Court held that Maharashtra, not Gujarat, was the because the trial had taken place there. It also found that the earlier order allowing Gujarat to consider the applications had been obtained by . The Court declared the remission invalid and directed the men to surrender within two weeks.
The Gujarat government released all 11 Bilkis Bano convicts through remission
Gujarat granted remission to 11 men serving life sentences and released them under the state’s . The decision immediately raised questions about whether Gujarat had authority to act because the trial had taken place in Maharashtra. The release triggered petitions challenging both the policy and the state’s jurisdiction.
The Supreme Court transferred Bilkis Bano’s trial from Gujarat to Maharashtra
The case arose from the 2002 Gujarat riots, when Bilkis Bano was gang-raped and seven members of her family were killed. The Supreme Court later transferred the investigation and trial to Maharashtra, where the convictions and life sentences were secured. That transfer became central to the later dispute over which state could decide .